Stuart Evers's piece on the Guardian Books Blog,
'The Costa short story prize is not enough' did the rounds on facebook earlier this week. Several of my writing friends shared the piece. I thought it was great. I agree with almost everything Evers said - you might think you can hear a 'however' coming, but it's going to be more of an 'and'...
Evers writes:
'There is only one UK prize dedicated to the short story collection, the Edge Hill Short Story Prize. And while that is a fantastic initiative, it simply doesn't have the reach, or the backing (or the money) of the BBC or the Times.'
I don't take issue with the above quotation, but I would like to respond to it:
Fiction writer and critic
Dr. Ailsa Cox founded the
Edge Hill Short Story Prize; she also runs it when she's not teaching, marking, supervising PhD students, writing a novel, writing short stories, and editing
Short Fiction in Theory and Practice.
I helped Ailsa with the 2011 prize and I'm also working on the 2012 prize, although 'working' is a bit of a misnomer - what we are really doing is volunteering because Evers is right, we don't have the money of the BBC or the Times.
The BBC has millions of pounds worth of air time - all free - to cross-promote its prize. The Sunday Times, a massive, high profile media platform, is bankrolled by city financiers desperate for respectability. Whereas Edge Hill, a small northern university, has generously underwritten its own prize to the tune of several thousand pounds a year for the last five years with no agenda except to recognise and encourage the short story form.
Ailsa and I squeeze the prize into the gaps in our lives - it sneaks between daily tasks like sand in a jar of marbles. I answer emails from publishers while I cook dinner for my 4 children, I notice a short story writer on facebook whose collection hasn't been entered and I send him a message while I'm having a break from writing my novel. I do this because I love short stories and I believe in the ethos of the prize. I don't want to download a single by a favourite artist when I can get the album; it's the same with short stories.
Despite our countless hours of work, the prize doesn't have the reach we would like. Why? Well, for starters, the broadsheets ignored us in 2011. Stuart Evers writes that Costa passed up on an opportunity to 'show the varied breadth of stories in this country' - so did the Guardian and every other broadsheet newspaper that didn't so much as mention the 2011 Edge Hill Prize.
Let me tell you what the broadsheets missed in 2011. They missed a
shortlist that included Helen Simpson, compared in
this Guardian review to Flannery O'Connor and Alice Munro; Michele Roberts, whose collection was described in a Financial Times
review as 'exhilarating' and 'lustrous'; Polly Samson whose story 'The Egg' from shortlisted collection
Perfect Lives was featured on Radio Four's
Book at Bedtime; exciting newcomer
Tom Vowler whose first novel will be published by
Headline in 2013; and eventual
winner of the 2011 Edge Hill Prize, Graham Mort, poet and short story writer par excellence.
The broadsheets also missed a longlist of exciting writers such as Vanessa Gebbie whose debut novel
The Coward's Tale was published last year and is reviewed in The Independent
here; Roshi Fernando whose Guardian
reviewed collection
Homesick will be re-released by Bloomsbury in 2012;
David Gaffney whose work has been reviewed by both the Guardian and The Independent; and fantastic debut collections by
Susannah Rickards,
Jo Canon and
Nik Perring among others.
My blog has a negligible reach. Still, maybe someone from the Guardian, or the Times, or the BBC might read this and see an opportunity to support the
only UK prize dedicated to the short story collection. Of course, it would be nice if there was an all-singing, all-dancing, cash rich prize that would 'take a risk' on short story collections. But there isn't. There's us. We're working really, really hard, and if newspapers like the Guardian are serious about short story collections, they can demonstrate it by reporting on the 2012 Edge Hill Prize.